Wednesday, 13 February 2013

Scotland would be a completely separate state under international law

A new report from the UK Government has this week made clear that an independent Scotland would be regarded as a completely separate state under international law.
Professors James Crawford and Alan Boyle, leading experts on international law, have produced a 58 page legal opinion which says the overwhelming weight of legal opinion makes clear the UK would be regarded by the international community as the ‘continuing state’. The legal opinion confirms that a vote for independence would make Scotland a ‘successor state’ and specifically rejects the proposition, advanced by Scotland’s First Minister, that Scotland and the UK would both be regarded as two new states following any vote for independence.
It is crucial that people are able to consider the benefits that Scotland enjoys as a nation of five million people in a modern, devolved country. This report makes clear what the legal situation is. No one disputes that Scotland could be a separate state, but it would be far from straightforward. As the Prime Minister has said recently, Britain works well. Why break it?
Scotland Office Minister, David Mundell MP said: ‘The devolution settlement is capable of change when the case is made as the Scotland Act 2012 delivered by this government has shown. So it is simply wrong to characterise the referendum as a choice between change and no change. By changing and adapting the devolution settlement will continue to deliver the best of both worlds for Scotland. Independence would end it.’

Trip to Downing Street

On Monday I attended a reception at 10 Downing Street. I had never been there before and it was quite a thrill to walk up the staircase lined with pictures and photographs of former prime ministers, which previously I had only ever seen on television.
I was delighted to meet David Cameron and pleased to hear him speak passionately about Scotland remaining within the United Kingdom.
This was my first visit to London for a number of years I stopped over to take in some of the sights, including the Victoria and Albert Museum given its link with Dundee.

Friday, 8 February 2013

Budget savings proposed

On Wednesday I submitted some additional savings to the council’s chief executive for consideration at the council budget meeting on 14th February. These include £6,916 that is spent on alcohol purchases for the City Chambers and £7,000 that is spent providing councillors with food and refreshments. I also proposed that £750,000, which is distributed to six electoral wards to fund local community projects be allocated equally in 2013/14 across the eight wards in the city including Broughty Ferry and the West End.
My intention in identifying additional savings was to save the Friendly Bus from being axed but thankfully the SNP administration has dropped that idea due to the representations that were made.
Although the savings I have identified are modest in comparison to the overall council spend I think council tax payers in Dundee will be surprised to learn that these items haven’t already been cut from the budget.
The terms of my savings proposals are as follow:
Provisional Revenue Budget & Review of Charges 2013/14:
1. Corporate Services / Corporate Finance
    Delete Budget for Councillors Attendance at Conferences - £1,000
2. Corporate Services / Support Services
    Delete Budget for Alcohol Purchases - £ 6,916
3. Various Departments – Delete Budget for Hospitality:
            Chief Executive - £ 4,000
            City Development - £ 6,100           
            Communities & Policy - £ 4,280
            Social Work - £ 3,930
            Environment -  £ 1,000
            Corporate Services - £ 6,50
4. Corporate Services / Support Services
    Delete Budget for Food & Refreshments for Councillors - £ 7,000

     Total Savings - £ 40,726

Wednesday, 6 February 2013

High hedges

I thought readers would be interested to learn that on Tuesday the Scottish Parliament debated Stage 1 of the High Hedges (Scotland) Bill. Representing an area that has a great many mature gardens I fairly regularly receive complaints about high hedges. At the moment any dispute about garden hedges which encroach on neighbouring properties is a civil matter. The new law if introduced will allow council’s to help resolve disputes about hedges of a certain height.
Scottish Conservative local government spokeswoman Margaret Mitchell MSP said: “This issue has been debated in the Scottish Parliament for nearly a decade. Disputes over high hedges can last a number of years, and can have an adverse effect on the health and wellbeing of both parties. Residents would be able to complain to councils on the basis that hedges on neighbouring land are considered to have an ‘adverse effect on the reasonable enjoyment of domestic property’.
 It’s important to note that this bill would be intended as an option of last resort. It’s also crucial that the cost of high hedge orders does not become so prohibitive that local authorities or applicants will not use them.”

Wednesday, 30 January 2013

Fortnightly bin collections

There has been a lot of comment in recent days about the council’s plan for fortnightly bin collections.
I raised the issue with the council’s director of environment and he confirmed his department are in the process of preparing a report to go to committee in March setting out the proposed future strategy for waste collection and recycling.
Apparently a number of scenarios have been considered all of which involve some form of weekly collections of waste being undertaken. However the key change will be about what it is that is collected on a weekly basis. I understand the council are looking at the introduction of fortnightly collections for residual waste i.e. household rubbish not able to be recycled, re-used or composted, but that any such proposal would be on the basis that there is an increase in the provision of recycling facilities and collections for residents across the city, which would offset the loss of a weekly collection for residual waste. The aim is to significantly reduce the amount of residual waste that has to collected and disposed of and to increase the amount of recyclate collected be it paper, metals, plastics or food.
The UK Government is opposed to fortnightly bin collections and has made money available to local authorities in England to retain weekly collections. When local government secretary Eric Pickles announced plans for a £250million fund he called weekly collections a basic right and described rubbish being taken away as the most visible council service people get.
I have concerns about the impact that fortnightly bin collections will have, including bad smells, vermin and seagull attacks on bin bags.
What do you think?  Let me know.

A fair referendum

The Electoral Commission, an impartial body, has today rejected the Scottish Government’s proposed referendum question. The commission has also urged the Scottish Government to provide the public with more facts on the implications of separation before the 2014 vote.
The Scottish Government’s proposed question is: “Do you agree that Scotland should be an independent country”.  The Electoral Commission said there were some aspects of the wording of this question that people felt were “potentially ambiguous or affected their perceptions of the neutrality of the question.” The formulation ‘Do you agree....’ was commonly felt to be biased towards a ‘yes’ outcome and potentially leading people towards a ‘yes’ vote. The Electoral Commission’s proposed question is: “Should Scotland be an independent country? Yes/No”

A proper reinstatement required

A proper reinstatement still needs to be carried out at this utility box on Brook Street at the corner with Fort Street. I raised the matter with the council’s network management team and was advised that the rough tarmac border at the installation is a temporary measure and it has been arranged for a council engineer to meet the BT contractor to discuss the requirements for the permanent reinstatement using the same granite paving slabs and finish as the adjacent area.
 I have yet to be advised of when the work will be undertaken but I will chase it up if nothing occurs in the near future. I think it is important when any street works are undertaken that the subsequent reinstatement is carried out timeously and to a reasonable standard.